2018年11月4日托福獨立寫作的考題是：A government spends money on a training course that train adults after the age of 25 in the most up-to-date skills in the workplace.Do you think it is effective?Why or why not?政府花錢為25歲以上人們培訓讓他們跟上時代潮流。你認為是否有效？牛學君為大家帶來寫作范文及解析。

A society needs a competent workforce equipped with up-to-date skills. Otherwise, it will be unproductive and fall behind the time. However, when the administration spends money on a nationwide work skills development training program where eligible trainees are only adults at the age of 25 or older, it should not expect the desired return.

一個社會需要一個有能力、有最新技能的勞動力。否則，它將是徒勞的，落后于時代。然而，當政府把錢花在全國范圍內的工作技能發展培訓項目上時，合格的受訓人員只有25歲或25歲以上的成年人，它不應該期望得到期望的回報。

First, the age of 25 may be a late point of start. Instead, an earlier age would be far desirable.

首先，25歲可能是起步較晚的時候。相反，更早的年齡是非常可取的。

Second, what is the scale of the program? Is a nationwide scale too wide?  A large-scale program will soon meet many difficulties: there may be regional differences that tear the program apart; there may be additional costs that add up to a colossal amount; there may be cases of corruption during the distribution of money to the local districts. For example, just as  a national school curriculum has to be alteredevery time as it is adopted in every individual region, a national training program has to go through the many times of change–too many to remain original. If the arrangement cannot remain the way it is, no effects should be credited to the original.

第二，這個項目的規模有多大?全國性的規模是否太大?大規模的項目很快就會遇到很多困難:可能會有地區差異導致項目破裂;可能會有額外的成本加起來會是一個巨大的數額;在向當地地區分配資金的過程中，可能會發生腐敗案件。例如，正如一個國家的學校課程必須隨著每個地區的采用而隨時改變一樣，一個國家的培訓計劃必須經歷多次的變化——太多了，以至于無法保持原創性。如果安排不能保持原來的方式，不應影響原來。

Third, is it an ongoing program at regular times? What if it cannot survive administrative changes and be a permanent undertaking?

第三，這是一個經常進行的項目嗎?如果它不能在行政變革中生存下來并成為一項永久性的事業，那該怎么辦?

To conclude, hardly can I be optimistic about the effectiveness of the program. I think it is more likely to be a failure or a borderline pass than to be a success.

總而言之，我很難對這個項目的有效性感到樂觀。我認為這更有可能是一個失敗或邊緣通行證而不是一個成功。

以上是是牛學君為大家整理的11月4日托福獨立寫作真題回憶范圍及解析，大家可以用來備考托福寫作。范文使用要合理，不建議大家背誦原文，只要學習表達和邏輯即可。最后，牛學君預祝大家取得理想的托福成績。